4.1 (414 ratings)

Not Your Crush's Cauldron: Supernatural Singles, Book 3

Name: Not Your Crush's Cauldron: Supernatural Singles, Book 3
Rating: 4.1 (414 reviews)
Author: April Asher
ISBN: B0CPTJS6D9

by April Asher

witches

About this book

Olive Maxwell has spent her entire life teaching about the supernatural world from the safety of a classroom, leaving the dangerous antics to her adventurous sisters. But when she realizes she has never actually lived a little, she creates a daring bucket list to force herself out of her comfort zone. Her first move? Becoming roommates with her long-time crush, the tattooed, motorcycle-riding, and perpetually troubled Guardian Angel, Baxter Donovan.

Bax is on his final warning with the celestial authorities, and his latest assignment is to keep the rule-abiding professor safe. As Olive begins checking off reckless stunts from her list, Bax finds himself in a high-stakes battle between his duty to protect her and his growing feelings. The tension between the buttoned-up witch and the fallen-from-grace angel is as electric as it is forbidden, making for a delightfully slow-burn romance.

Set within a compelling academy backdrop, this paranormal romance blends whimsical magic with deep emotional stakes. It is a heartwarming, spicy, and funny conclusion to the Maxwell sisters' journey that reminds us that sometimes the biggest risks are the ones we take with our hearts. If you crave cozy supernatural vibes with a dash of divine trouble, this is your next obsession.

Publication Date: May 25, 2026
ASIN: B0CPTJS6D9

Reader Reviews

Love it

March 3, 2024

I'll admit this one wasn't my favorite of the trilogy but it was still super cute and super good. I personally loved the lessons in it too. It was wholesome and fun. ) One person found this helpful

Loved the E-Book and Audio

February 14, 2024

Let me start with saying the Supernatural Singles series is a wonderfully sweet, funny and spicy series that is a delight to read. 💗Not the Witch You Wed 💗Not Your Exes Hexes 💗Not Your Crush’s Cauldron These books follow the three Maxwell sisters on their journey of self discovery, power and love. Not Your Crush’s Cauldron is the third in the series following Olive Maxwell the studious and goal oriented Maxwell sister as she leaves an unsavory living situation to move In with her friend Bax...

Supernatural romance with very, very slow burn

April 1, 2024

Not Your Crush's Cauldron is the 3rd book in the series about the Maxwell witch triplets. It features Olive, a professor of supernatural studies, and Bax, a guardian angel. While both have crushed on each other for a long time, neither has admitted their feelings to the other. When Olive makes a list of challenges to move out of her comfort zone, Bax is appointed to watch over her. Because of guardian angel rules, he can't tell her or confess how he feels. The book reunites the casts from the...

So cute!

February 19, 2024

🖤 Paranormal 🖤 Roommates 🖤 Plus size FMC 🖤 HEA Quotes “Be careful what you ask for, angel. If I put my arms around you, I may not let you go.” “Not to rush or anything, but we’ve developed quite a crowd out here, and they’re looking a bit eager to see some ink on skin. Not skin on skin... although I could be reading the room wrong.” “It wasn’t what you did that moved you forward the most, but the people who stood by your side when you did it.” Olive is a witch who moves in with Bax the...

Saved the best for last in the series

November 26, 2025

4.5⭐️ I loved the third book in the Supernatural Singles series. I loved getting Bax and Olive's love story. I think Olive is the Maxwell sister I most identified with, so finally reading her story had me kicking my feet. Bax was a swoon worthy MMC and he was so down bad for Olive from the very beginning. I also enjoyed getting updates on all the other couples from the previous books. These stories had the best ensemble cast that I just fell in love with all of them. I'm kind of sad the series...